Very rarely, if at all, do I read manga/graphic novels. This is one time that I did. I love the Warriors and Warriors; New Prophecy series. I also have read some Warriors; Super Edition books and enjoyed them. Ravenpaw is one of my favorite characters from the original Warriors series. I was excited to read a book all about Ravenpaw. It was good, but just something about it..... I guess manga isn't really my thing. So, it was good, but not good enough to give it more than three stars.